Music in the Liturgy cover

Music in the Liturgy is a new CTS title, an introduction for those with some interest though perhaps not an expertise in this area.

Here the author, Ben Whitworth, explains the genesis of the text and his reasons for writing it.

What does the Catholic Mass sound like? Most people outside the Church would expect the music of Catholic worship to involve Gregorian chant and choral polyphony. This was certainly how I imagined Catholic Church music before I had ever been to a Mass. And, as it happens, my expectations were fulfilled: at the age of eighteen I went to the Catholic Chaplaincy in Cambridge, and experienced a sung Latin Mass with a polyphonic choir.

However, I soon discovered that this was far from typical of Catholic Sunday worship; and I began to wonder why. Now, after twenty years in the pews, and fifteen years in the choir lofts of Catholic parish churches, I am still intrigued by the wide variety of music that is heard in our Eucharistic celebrations.

Pope Benedict XVI has stated: “Certainly, as far as the liturgy is concerned, we cannot say that one song is as good as another.”

But what are the criteria for evaluating liturgical song? What does the Church propose as suitable music for Mass? What can we draw from the long tradition of Catholic music? How should we choose what is sung, and by whom? What, indeed, is liturgical music for?

These questions came into focus for me a few years ago, when I was asked to help with music for Masses at the Italian Chapel in Orkney. This is an extraordinary place of worship – built and decorated by Italian prisoners-of-war during World War II – and it seemed imperative to get things right. But how?

I have tried to address this question in my booklet by returning to the sources of a Christian understanding of music: sacred Scripture; the lives of the Saints; the writings of the Fathers and the great theologians; the teaching of Popes and Councils; the history of sacred music; and the liturgical books themselves.

Of course, whole books have been written on this subject (recent volumes by William Mahrt, Joseph P. Swain, and Anthony Ruff are particularly stimulating). What I have tried to produce is a concise overview, for the non-specialist reader, of the theology, history, and current practice of music at Mass, taking into account the new English translation of the Roman Missal and the resources that are available today. I hope it will prove interesting, informative and thought-provoking for musicians, clergy, or anyone who simply wants to know more about what we sing in church.

Music in the Liturgy by Ben Whitworth, is available from CTS priced £2.50

Read an extract


Of related interest:

The Cover of Sacrifice in the Liturgy Sacrifice in the Liturgy -Bishop Peter Elliot helps us to understand the Christian sacrifice given to us at the Last Supper by reflecting on the shape of the liturgy, its actions and symbols, particularly the altar and sacred space set apart for the Eucharistic sacrifice.
Participating in the Mass Participating in the Mass – Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, provides an informative, step-by-step guide to the celebration of the Mass, to enable the Liturgy to be celebrated with reverence, dignity and beauty.
RM08 Missa Cantata – Organ music to accompany the singing of those parts of the new English Mass translation sung by the entire assembly.

In the 4th and final part of his exclusive interview with journalist Peter Jennings, Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB reacts to a compliment and talks about working with the CTS.

Peter Jennings: Someone wrote on a blog (this very blog in fact) that your CTS booklet “Participating in the Mass” should be obligatory reading. What is your reaction to this?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson: I welcome the blogger’s remark as a compliment rather than a call to impose it on anyone. The late Cardinal Virgilio Noe’, former Master of Ceremonies to Pope Paul VI, with whom I worked in the Congregation for Divine Worship, once said to me: “We are not policemen; we are here to serve, to assist the Holy Father and the Church”. It is worth recalling that Cardinal Noe’s father was actually an Italian policeman!

Like every short study this booklet has its limitations. I have tried to write something that will encourage both priests and lay-faithful to deepen their liturgical life. Priests today need to be encouraged. Priests do not have any easy task and the good they do is not always seen or appreciated. If we all try to make improvements, then little by little we will see positive results. But whatever we do it must always be done in such a way that as Saint Benedict says: “In all things God may be glorified”.

Peter Jennings: Finally, I should like to ask you one further question. You have already contributed three booklets published by the CTS about the liturgy. The two titles already mentioned – see below – and a third, “A Simple Guide to the Mass“. Are you working or planning any further publications?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson: The CTS has dedicated itself in an admirable way to providing for the liturgical needs of the Church in Great Britain.

The quality of these works, especially the edition of the Missal, is evident and a real and lasting contribution to the beautiful character of the liturgy.
Fergal Martin, General Secretary of the CTS, and his staff, have been most helpful to me. I have enjoyed collaborating with them. I have been encouraged to continue to produce more pastoral liturgical publications and am looking forward to starting work on these new projects.

Participating in the Mass is available from the CTS website priced £2.50


Of related interest:

D745 Simple Guide to the Mass – Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, a Consultor to the Vatican Congregation for Divine Worship, provides a simple and concise guide to the new translation of the Mass introduced by the Church on Sunday, 4 September 2011. Pope Benedict XVI has expressed the wish that the introduction of the new translation will mark the beginning of: “A renewal and a deepening of Eucharistic devotion all over the English-speaking world”.
LT03 Participating in the Mass -Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, in this companion to his widely acclaimed CTS booklet Understanding the Roman Missal, provides an informative, step-by-step guide to the celebration of the Mass, to enable the Liturgy to be celebrated with reverence.
LT02 Understanding the Roman Missal – the New Translation -A presentation and explanation of the new translation, accompanied by liturgical and spiritual reflections. This presentation and explanation of the new translation is accompanied by a series of liturgical and spiritual reflections.

In the 3rd part of his exclusive interview with journalist Peter Jennings for CTS, Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB tells us little things matter, but warns against the Liturgy becoming a precise theatre.

Peter Jennings: I was impressed by your quotations from the writings of Pope Benedict XVI, especially his words: “The beauty of the Liturgy is a sublime expression of God’s glory”. How do you interpret these particular words of the Holy Father?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson: The Liturgy, no matter where or in what rite it is celebrated is intrinsically beautiful, and this is the true meaning of Father Faber’s words that the Mass is: “The most beautiful thing this side of heaven”. The Roman Rite, the Ambrosian Rite, the various Eastern Rites and now the rite of our own newly established Ordinariate are all a beautiful thing and a sublime expression of God’s glory.

Whether celebrated in a magnificent cathedral or in a humble mission station devoid of decoration, whether in Latin or any other liturgical language this always is and always will be “the Mass of the ages”.

Peter Jennings: Many of the suggestions in your new CTS booklet strike me as being very practical and down to earth. Yet you insist on the need for a theological underpinning. Please elaborate on this?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson: Perhaps you have in mind the remark that standards in church should be no less than that required in secular society, especially as regards behaviour, body language and dress code.

Well, we have to begin somewhere and small practical details can contribute to the work of enhancing the beauty and dignity of the Liturgy. Moments of silence before the celebration help to create the right atmosphere in which we can enter into the presence of God singing for joy. Let everything be in its right place and everyone know when and how to perform his or her particular function. There should be nothing artificial or affected, nothing that appears military in its style and precision.

Quite simply the putting into practice the of art of celebration is taking care to do what is right and contributes to the building up of the body of Christ. Even in moving about and in gestures we could learn something from the discipline of stage directions yet without becoming theatrical.

In the last part of the interview which we will publish tomorrow, Abbot Cuthbert will talk about working with the CTS.

Participating in the Mass is available from the CTS website priced £2.50


Of related interest:

D745 Simple Guide to the Mass – Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, a Consultor to the Vatican Congregation for Divine Worship, provides a simple and concise guide to the new translation of the Mass introduced by the Church on Sunday, 4 September 2011. Pope Benedict XVI has expressed the wish that the introduction of the new translation will mark the beginning of: “A renewal and a deepening of Eucharistic devotion all over the English-speaking world”.
LT03 Participating in the Mass -Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, in this companion to his widely acclaimed CTS booklet Understanding the Roman Missal, provides an informative, step-by-step guide to the celebration of the Mass, to enable the Liturgy to be celebrated with reverence.
LT02 Understanding the Roman Missal – the New Translation -A presentation and explanation of the new translation, accompanied by liturgical and spiritual reflections. This presentation and explanation of the new translation is accompanied by a series of liturgical and spiritual reflections.

In the 2nd part of his exclusive interview with journalist Peter Jennings for CTS, Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, tells us about his own background and the vital importance of music in the liturgy.

Peter Jennings: The Church has given many directives about the Liturgy so what more needs to be done?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson: Directives and instructions are necessary and we have had an abundance of them, some may say we have had far too many. Indeed all that needs to be said has been said. For this reason the booklet “Participating in the Mass” is not a series of do’s and don’ts. It is an attempt to help us understand the liturgical, theological and spiritual dimension of the directives which ensure good order and dignity when we celebrate the sacred Liturgy.

No matter how faithful the observance of ceremonial and rubrics might be, no matter how elegant the vestments and ornamentations of the church might be, this will not of itself ensure that conscious and active participation which leads us to share and live the mystery of Christ in the Liturgy.

Peter Jennings: I know that you have always had a keen interest in the liturgy form the time that we first knew each other at school in Scotland over fifty years ago. Tell me something of your experiences over the years.

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson: My interest in the Liturgy stems from my parish church on Tyneside where my uncle was the organist and choirmaster.

I always preferred to serve the sung Mass on a Sunday. The choir sang simple Gregorian chant antiphons and the Masses of Sir Richard Terry the first Master of Music at Westminster Cathedral. When I joined the monastery in 1964, I received encouragement from Dom Henry Ashworth to pursue the study of the Liturgy. I was able to pursue the technical side of both the Liturgy and the Chant at the Abbey of Solesmes in France and in Rome.

After obtaining a doctorate in Liturgical Theology, I was called to the Vatican to work in the Congregation for Divine Worship from 1983 to 1996.

Peter Jennings: I know you have co-authored about 16 volumes on the sources of the Latin liturgy and written numerous articles in International Reviews and the richness of your experience come through in your writing. With such experience, how do you see the development of the liturgy?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson: While we must always trust in the Lord, we must take care not to presume upon His goodness and kindness. To expect great improvements without making an effort to bring them about, is like asking the Lord to change stones into bread. Musicians, artists and all who work in the sphere of the Liturgy need to be encouraged and not just by words. Music and works of art need to be commissioned. And Bursaries could be set up to help young Catholic musicians and artists.

Those who can contribute to the development of the aesthetic dimension of worship need to be helped to what is meant by sacred art and learn from the Church’s rich musical patrimony.

Peter Jennings: Please give me a specific example?

Abbot Johnson: On Easter morning, the Introit as given in the Gregorian Chant version, is in the contemplative and meditative fourth mode. The words and melody suggests the image of one who has awoken from sleep, who lays aside the shroud and wraps up the cloth which was about his head.
Gregorian chant has its joyful and vigorous modes, but the Church chooses to open the Easter Mass in the awesome contemplation of the mystery of the Resurrection.

It is to the silent yet eloquent testimony of the tomb that the Church guides our attention, for only the tomb witnessed that saving event. Many composers might be tempted to open the Easter Day celebration with a fanfare of trumpets and multiple “alleluias”. This is another and equally valid approach but would we not be losing a precious insight if we overlooked this other dimension?

By studying such ancient examples in both music and art we can learn so much and enrich our faith.

More tomorrow.

Participating in the Mass is available from the CTS website priced £2.50


Of related interest:

D745 Simple Guide to the Mass – Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, a Consultor to the Vatican Congregation for Divine Worship, provides a simple and concise guide to the new translation of the Mass introduced by the Church on Sunday, 4 September 2011. Pope Benedict XVI has expressed the wish that the introduction of the new translation will mark the beginning of: “A renewal and a deepening of Eucharistic devotion all over the English-speaking world”.
LT03 Participating in the Mass -Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, in this companion to his widely acclaimed CTS booklet Understanding the Roman Missal, provides an informative, step-by-step guide to the celebration of the Mass, to enable the Liturgy to be celebrated with reverence.
LT02 Understanding the Roman Missal – the New Translation -A presentation and explanation of the new translation, accompanied by liturgical and spiritual reflections. This presentation and explanation of the new translation is accompanied by a series of liturgical and spiritual reflections.

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, during an exclusive interview with journalist Peter Jennings for CTS, explains how priests and the lay faithful should work closely together to achieve a standard of liturgical celebration which is both dignified and beautiful.

Peter Jennings: Your first CTS booklet, “Understanding the Roman Missal” has been well received. How does your new publication “Participating in the Mass – Celebrating the Liturgy with dignity & beauty” (available now) relate to it?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB: There is a widespread desire not only in the Catholic Church in Great Britain but elsewhere to celebrate the Liturgy with dignity and beauty.

This booklet carefully explains that mere external and aesthetic issues, important though these may be, are not of themselves enough. There is a need for all of us, priests and lay-faithful people, to learn the art of celebration. This is a skill which enables us to exercise correctly that full, conscious, and active participation in the Liturgy first called for by the Church more one hundred years ago and yet still not fully understood today.

Peter Jennings: In what particular way is the full, conscious, and active participation in the Liturgy not fully understood?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson:The expression full, conscious, and active participation should be understood within the context of the Church’s teaching on the Liturgy. Participation is first and foremost sharing in the Divine Life through the saving work of our Lord Jesus Christ. In the words of Saint Peter we are partakers of the Divine nature.

Participation is a disposition of mind and heart, body and soul. In general terms we understand participation as simply taking part in an event. Whereas in the liturgy our participation is not conditioned by what we do but by what we are: co-heirs with Christ and sharers in the Divine nature. Because of this everyone, irrespective of personal disability or restricted ability is able to participate fully and meaningfully in the Liturgy.

Peter Jennings: From what you have said so far, I understand that it is not by doing things in the Liturgy that one participates but by the fact of being baptised. Is this correct?

Abbot Cuthbert Johnson: Yes, you are right and put in another way, participation as understood in this way is the exercise of the priesthood of all the faithful, We are a Royal Priesthood, a Holy Nation, a People Set Apart. There is indeed a diversity of roles to be fulfilled in the celebration of the liturgy. Those who exercise them in a way which edifies everyone is one manifestation of the actualising of our baptismal responsibilities as members of the Body of Christ.

More on Monday!

Participating in the Mass is available from the CTS website priced £2.50


Of related interest:

D745 Simple Guide to the Mass – Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, a Consultor to the Vatican Congregation for Divine Worship, provides a simple and concise guide to the new translation of the Mass introduced by the Church on Sunday, 4 September 2011. Pope Benedict XVI has expressed the wish that the introduction of the new translation will mark the beginning of: “A renewal and a deepening of Eucharistic devotion all over the English-speaking world”.
LT03 Participating in the Mass -Abbot Cuthbert Johnson OSB, in this companion to his widely acclaimed CTS booklet Understanding the Roman Missal, provides an informative, step-by-step guide to the celebration of the Mass, to enable the Liturgy to be celebrated with reverence.
LT02 Understanding the Roman Missal – the New Translation -A presentation and explanation of the new translation, accompanied by liturgical and spiritual reflections. This presentation and explanation of the new translation is accompanied by a series of liturgical and spiritual reflections.


Donate To CTS

Login